
When I first saw this promo shot for Dane Cook's Isolated Incident, which premiered Sunday night, I thought it was intended to convey an older, wiser, and darker Dane - that he had finally tossed the whole frat boy image. Well, he did, sort of. He was still decked out in tee shirt and jeans, but he was a lot less animated, a lot less loud, and a little darker.
I long ago gave up being a Dane Cook hater. I never liked his act much, and I didn't find this new hour all that great, either, but I've been doing comedy just long enough to realize that the only people who care about a comics' success, relative to every other comic, are other comics (and a small but rabid core of fans who have never done comedy but feel qualified to judge everyone who does).
Try telling one of the millions of Denis Leary fans that a few of his funniest bits on
No Cure for Cancer were lifted from Bill Hicks, and the likely response will be, "Who's
Bill Hicks?" That's not to say I condone stealing material. I don't - it is the cardinal sin in comedy. But if Dane Cook lifted material from Louis C.K., that's between Dane Cook and Louis C.K. It's not as if I would have headlined The Laugh Factory for a televised special last month if Dane Cook had been exiled from comedy, so what business is it of mine?
If I were forced at gunpoint to bet money on who lifted what from whom in the whole Hicks/Leary debate, yeah, I'd bet the material in question was Hicks', if only because Leary never demonstrated that level of creative genius afterward. But I don't know, and I don't care. To anyone who still cares about this tired debate 18 years after
No Cure... and 15 years after Hicks' DEATH, two things:
- Hicks and Leary worked together. More than once. They did Montreal at the same time. They were also notorious drinkers and inhalers of Peruvian marching powder, so who knows - really - what may have been bandied back and forth between lines gakked up off the back of some green room toilet?
- Write something that anyone would want to steal, or shut the fuck up. Thanks.